U.S. Launches Fresh Assault on Apple’s ‘Warrant-Proof Encryption’
forbes.com
forbes.com
Love this speculation about a non-existent mystery iPhone model when a quick search reveals that yes, iPhone12,5 is the model number for 11 Pro Max.
They're starting out with the "think of the children" argument. Which means you know from the outset they are likely not being genuine in their pursuit of this.
> "...enact legislation to ensure lawful access for law enforcement, consistent with the traditional protections of privacy, to digital evidence of crime."
They can make the legislation all they want. The traditional protections of privacy cannot apply to the digital evidence of crime. The digital playing field is far more level than the physical playing field.
In the physical world, a lock acts as a deterrent, but not much more.
In the digital world, a lock doesn't generally act as a deterrent. You just throw more computing power at it until it breaks, or you find a simpler way to make it break. If you know a lock is vulnerable, because it has legislated to be, you have every incentive and no deterrent to find the weakness in that lock.
In the physical world, agents of another country are generally not a relevant concern.
In the digital world, any multinational platform has to be aware of multinational efforts to control discourse, including hacking of important and/or old accounts.
The digital world is much more akin to a group of embassies located side-by-side each other than the average person's home.
By this disingenuous framing, a pad of paper is also "warrant-proof" - after all the government is unable to issue a single directive to the manufacturer and obtain a copy of everything written on pads they produced, or prevent their pages from being hidden or burnt. Society has gotten along just fine with the police having to do policework, rather than being able to just set up a panopticon.
Wouldn't that make ANY end-to-end encryption "warrant-proof"?
Yes. And the legislative community around those involved in the intelligence service would rather cripple e2e with magic keys than allow it to continue to protect everyone.