That seems harsh. The article runs ~ 1300 words, which is right for a short feature and how conclusive can an investigation into a "mystery" be? There's no claim they solved it
The investigation seems to be they checked the database and emailed 2 or 3 firms or got a call with them to ask “is this you”. Was there more to it?
Normally this piece would be the piece you’d give your editor to say “looks like no ready answer, would you pay me to do an investigation?”
Would you prefer that no news outlet writes about it until the mystery is solved and wrapped up with a neat bow?