The best science PhDs are neither willing to follow orders nor conforming, but you're right about #1 and 4 :)
1. it has not been proved to work,
2. it didn't work in a specific case,
3. my replacement method is mathematically rigorous.
And that is why I work for a megacorp, at the moment.
If so, then who doesn't consider that a "job", and why should we care that they have this bizarre viewpoint?