Hacker News Reader

Comment by sschueller | Hacker News Reader

At what point are we going to stop with this Nationalism bullshit and realize that research, regardless of who pays for it, is good for all of mankind.

View on HN

A good sentiment which doesnt work when bad faith actors take advantage of openness to capitalize on the race to profitable product by standing on (and not sharing with) the folks who struggle with and funded the enabling R&D. Free and Open Research is Knowledge as a Commons, and is just as vulnerable to bad faith actors as any other Tragedy of thr Commons.

When the national and global patent systems are reformed or eliminated.

As soon as we have removed all of the silly lines on the map.

I think the realization that research is better of without boundaries can be effectuated a whole lot earlier than removing all of the silly lines on the map. In fact it may well be a long time before removing the silly lines on the map is even a good idea.

Everytime I see someone mentioning no nations, fictitious as it is, it reminds me of https://acecombat.fandom.com/wiki/A_World_With_No_Boundaries which was branded as a terrorist group in the game. Don't think national boundaries will ever be erased without economic incentive and hardship in the process. How would you refer to each land?

As far as I can see there is always going to be boundaries be it cultural, tribal or artificial. Tendency is just there. Look at SF for instance where there was one neighborhood that rebranded itself (The East cut).

Nation-states are a fairly recent invention historically speaking, and their benefits are somewhat questionable - it's entirely possible that they simply don't provide more benefits than the price of administration.

Humans lived in city-states for most of our history, I see no reason why we shouldn't expect the city-state to be resurgent in the current century.

And this is exactly what software engineers and other high-impact people should aim to do eventually.

As soon as the Chinese stop with it too

Reply on news.ycombinator.com