What's your threat model?
Apple TV is a pragmatic option for the sort of person that doesn't mind the Apple Walled Garden.
Xbox One is a pragmatic option for the sort of person that doesn't mind the Xbox/Microsoft Walled Garden.
NVidia Shield and FireTV are pragmatic options for folks that prefer the more Android-ish "mostly a Walled Garden, but".
If your threat model is anything with a corporate or walled garden smell, then sure none of them can be trusted and just build your own media PC with Linux and whichever apps you feel you can trust.