In the scenario where NSA gave Microsoft a public key to include in the product Microsoft doesn't have the private key. That's the point-- NSA would want their own root-of-trust in the product.
The fact that they haven't reinforces the argument that they don't own the private key (likely, the NSA does as the conspiracy goes)
It would also be trivial for Microsoft to call up the NSA and say "they're ON TO US and it looks bad to our customers, can you please sign this message?" That is, the test you suggest proves nothing-- you can't prove that only you hold a private key.
Pardon my pedantry but I think you meant conspiracy theory. Conspiracies happen all the time, and by itself the word doesn't imply anything far-fetched or unproven, just plotting to do harm.
Maybe next time I'll write a paragraph shrugs
Time for me to find another community.