It's interesting to see that Scoble puts ESR's post in the same sack as the rest of the "nuts", yet doesn't do much to refute it. It's almost as if he read only the title.
The ESR post has no basis in reality. The announcement will "split nokia in half"? How does he think it's structured right now? Nokia is split sixteen different ways inside already, it's a total mess of competing agendas and technologies.
Eric's point is that Nokia's move does not do anything to address this and might even make it worse.