Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by robinshen | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

robinshen

Wow! That is interesting, :D Will try to see what happens.

View on HN

FYI - your code does not build for me because of dependency resolution issues.

Not sure why.

I'm using latest Idea.

Please run below from command line first to see if it works:

mvn clean package

yes. it does. basically the standard ide was croaking on your use of a private artifactory.

Any particular reason why you have structured this way ? could you not pull all your source code in a single build process ?

gradle will make the builds very effective - extremely performant on modular builds

I put some common libraries into a private artifactory as I want to reduce the whole build time. The reason I am using Maven build instead of Gradle is that I can use M2E in Eclipse which can compile the project incrementally very fast while I am editing files.

It's not advisable to split code like this. The better way is to use gradle and make it a multi-module build. First time will take time , but each time it will only compile incrementally. Blazing fast and good management.

All of android now uses this, so this is not new

My main concern is that gradle might not work as well as M2E in Eclipse which makes incremental compiling blazing fast (less than 1 sec for editing and compiling)

Thanks! As long as maven works for you, just stick to it.

I'm also happy that it is plain Java as it means I can contribute without learning IntelliJ or anything special.

Thanks for willing to contribute. I will write some guideline for that later. Also it is possible to develop in IntelliJ, just that you need to run "mvn compile" from command line every time you changes the dependencies. While in Eclipse, it is fully automated with help of M2E.

No worries. For some reason I personally prefer NetBeans and Eclipse to IntelliJ, that's why I appreciate that you stick with plain Java and Maven instead of Kotlin and Gradle :-)

gradle works on commandline. Gradle has nothing to do with intellij.

Gradle supports modular building and other cool things that improves productivity. And a gradle build file is like 1/10th of a POM.XML file. Try it sometime.

I didn't say that Gradle demanded IntelliJ.

What I meant was that if author had switched to Kotlin it would have been hard to contribute without IntelliJ.

Gradle (as Buildship) is a top level supported project in Eclipse.

https://github.com/eclipse/buildship

you will be pleasantly surprised.

https://www.vogella.com/tutorials/EclipseGradle/article.html

But more importantly, i do request you would create a single source repo. your private dependency system is bit hard to work with. Even if you use mvn

Eventually I will move those libraries to maven central for better public access.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com