Alliance with Microsoft seems to be the only sensible choice for Nokia at the moment. True story.
Alliance with Microsoft seems to be the only sensible choice for Nokia at the moment. True story.
Many people disagree with you. Imagine that.
I suspect you're not old enough to remember the fate of some other Microsoft "partners" of this sort.
Partnerships don't work out, but there doesn't seem to be many examples in that list of Microsoft leaving those partners out to dry, it's just a case of the product wasn't good enough (from both Microsoft and the phone manufacturers).
They brought an OS from MS and that destroyed their biggest bet ever, reducing them from the hardware maker to just another supplier.
OS/2 was a horrible hit to IBM, and Microsoft is a huge part of why OS/2 went so horribly awry (IBM also made many strategic mistakes of their own, so it's not just that Microsoft behaved in a duplicitous way).
Furthermore, to characterize Microsoft as the dominate player in that partnership is simply rewriting history.
In both cases, the other party made many strategic mistakes, but Microsoft did many things to contribute to their downfall.
Others have mentioned Compaq (whose history is not one of unmarred success) and Dell, but those are companies that exist because of Microsoft, and have pretty much never gone against Microsoft's wishes. It took years before Dell started offering Linux boxes, and even now, the Dell Linux line is more expensive and lower quality than the equivalent Windows systems. For instance, when I was shopping for a laptop, the only Linux laptop from Dell had a non-LED and lower resolution display than the much cheaper Windows equivalent. Same model number, but the Linux version was crappy and $200 more. I bought the Windows version and put Linux on it with no driver issues, so it wasn't that they had to make compromises to make it all work...they just like toeing the line for Microsoft. (It's turned out to be a crappy laptop, anyway, so I won't be buying another Dell.)
Microsoft needed Nokia at least as much as Nokia needed Microsoft here.
Welcome to HN. I take it you're new here?
Your wisdom ends where Nokia's share price begins. Seriously, the whole market read this as a stupid move where far better, saner, alternatives were available.