Women obviously bear the majority of the stress (carrying the baby, unavoidable thoughts of 'what did I do to cause this?', etc.), but as the spouse in this situation it was always nice - though relatively rare - when friends/coworkers/etc. would check in on me and ask how I'm doing. I don't have PTSD, but I'm definitely not the same as I was before my wife's first loss.
A good rule of thumb is to treat people with compassion and support, because you don’t know what they are going through.
> Not sure why you're being downvoted
I find that people on Hacker News tend to downvote any kind of short comments. When I came across this thread, it was empty and I didn't like seeing an empty thread, so I wanted to say something to break the ice. (At this point, the post has 18 points, so clearly cooler heads prevailed.)
My wife tells stories about seeing her father suddenly start sobbing when she came across items that her parents bought for their first pregnancy.
Later, when we had a miscarriage, (fortunately very early,) my boss told me about his. Even though we were on the phone, I could tell he was holding back tears.
Thankfully we haven't had serious fertility problems. What helped in our case was, throughout my life, hearing about my parents' miscarriage, sister's miscarriage, cousin's miscarriage. I knew it was normal.
Of course close family [that know about it] will also feel grief; that’s only natural. I think the point being made is that it is far worse for the individual doing the actual miscarrying. On top of the grief there can also be powerful feelings of guilt, anger, personal responsibility; plus they’ve a bloody great biochemical hurricane going down too.
(e.g. Compare and contrast the effects of postpartum depression following a successful pregnancy.)
Look, no-one says grieving spouses don’t require support too (of course they do!), but it’s entirely reasonable to suggest that women who miscarry suffer more severe trauma requiring significantly higher and more specialized professional support. Terms like “PTSD” and “medication“ do not get bandied around for fun, you know. Particularly by a medical profession that has a less-than-perfect history of taking “female problems” seriously.
So try starting from the assumption that however bad it may make you feel, the other person feels a whole shit-ton worse, and show some flipping grace as you work your way from there.
Then you're missing the personal experience to contribute meaningfully to this discussion.
So now do you want to know why I initially posted? Because as soon as a discussion about women was brought up, a bunch of men came in and made it about themselves. I may not have kids but at least I have empathy and a working theory of mind, along with occasional manners. Congrats.
The comparison (to my understanding) is wholly in your comment.
I’m not sure why you are comparing. I’m genuinely not sure. Prior to your comment there didn’t seem to be any discussion about for whom it was more traumatic.
Maybe I’m missing something? Some implied context or content?
Like all things this depends on the individuals involved, and while it's probably usually worse for the female (the hormonal effects you mention are very real), this is absolutely not a universal truth, especially in the longer term.
Then, when we got pregnant again, and it sticked, she felt better, and it passed for her for good.
Meanwhile I was holding my breath for years. I'm still trying to recover from this loss, 7 years on. We have 2 beautiful, perfect, healthy twin girls. They're baby 2 and 3. We're so lucky with them... And they're quite the handful !...
But I still think almost daily of the little one we lost. It's still very, very painful to me. Therapy and EMDR help, but man...