This exact same prediction was made in 2007. These sorts of predictions are no better than what a fortune teller can offer.
[1]: https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2009/sep...
This exact same prediction was made in 2007. These sorts of predictions are no better than what a fortune teller can offer.
[1]: https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2009/sep...
I reckon its because there is a social and possible economic price to pay to say anything that detracts from a sense of emergency around the climate. It is a toxic culture now similar to that of the 'woke' wing of the left or the pro-gun wing of the right.
If anyone wants the general public to take this issue as seriously as it should be FUD is not the way to go. I think it hurts more than it helps.
If scientists knew how to fix science journalism, we would. It's not just climate. Cancer research and diet research have the same problem, and if battery capacity had doubled for every headline saying it had, we would be charging our phones once a year. But the science journalists argue that they're not lying, just picking the most interesting stories, and that otherwise no one would read them at all. If scientists came out with a statement that science journalism is a fraud, it might be sensational enough to make the news, but it wouldn't be true. If they said science journalism needs reform - well, I'm sure you can find plenty of blog posts arguing this, but not a lot of media coverage.
You're arguing the extremes here. Scientific organizations could easily publicize their displeasure with how their work is communicated to the public without calling the media fraudsters. Give me a break.
https://www.nature.com/news/science-journalism-can-be-eviden...
I admit I'm speculating a bit when I try to explain why reforming science journalism is difficult, but I'm pretty sure empirically that it is difficult.
It's a good thing science makes progress every day, just start listening.
Whoops.
This article actually confirms the loss of arctic ice sheets because water levels are still rising despite gains in antarctic ice.
It's been flat since 2007 in the arctic. Sea Ice in the Antarctic has actually had a record high in that time period.
http://nsidc.org/arcticseaicenews/files/1999/10/Figure3.png
Specifically, 2012 was such an extreme year that the following years seldom compete with it, but they still do, and the trend to decrease is still obvious.
Actually, in 2019 and 2020 at more dates the sea extent was under that of the same dates in 2012, except for the extreme points in September:
2020:
https://nsidc.org/data/seaice_index/images/daily_images/N_iq...
2019: see July: http://nsidc.org/arcticseaicenews/files/1999/10/Figure3.png
https://web.archive.org/web/20150912124604/http://www.indepe...
I'm not sure why you read this as a prediction. The article mentions how this statement was made in 2007, a year that saw "record melt all over the Arctic." This fact probably accounts for the "at this rate" qualifier used above. The phrase "nearly ice-free" is also not the same as "no ice."
==I am not saying climate change isn't happening but predictions like this are not useful.==
Maybe it is more about how you frame things in your mind. In this case, you inferred a prediction and used that to discredit the scientific data.
> you inferred a prediction and used that to discredit the scientific data.
I did no such thing. I discredited the interpretation of scientific data. Huge difference compadre.
Either way, you still manage to ignore the phrase "could be nearly ice-free", as that discredits your entire assumption that he predicted it would be ice-free in 2012.