The competition is around serving the most relevant monetizable information. Google’s search quality for static content is arguably decreasing, while that kind of Search is a service I would personally like to pay for.
If Google were to “split up”, I as a customer would like a paid-for, transparant, utility search on one hand. My money can go to dealing with SEO abuse. On the other hand as a business I would like an ad-serving product, to which customers can voluntarily subject themselves to.
The two organizations would have to become separate business units, because I don’t want what’s currently happening: I search for information and get disinformation that others paid for.