Offering HTTP allows MITM attackers to strip HTTPS from visitors who want it. HSTS can help, but the vector still exists.
Optional security is not just an upgrade; it opens up a downgrade path from more secure to less.
Optional security is not just an upgrade; it opens up a downgrade path from more secure to less.
Also encryption is neither security nor privacy.
[0] What do you think of that S?
Someone in a cousin comment made another, maybe better point: URLs get linked and crawled and cached and having them HTTP just normalizes something that was fine in 1995 but isn't fine in 2020.
It's always possible for someone to get proxied like you said, but it's still safer overall if ever seeing "http://" raises eyebrows. There's another front page thread [1] right now about the normalization of deviance.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22136710 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22144330