Their major problem is that Facebook is an uneasy partner. Zygna make far more per-user than Facebook do and if they could, FB would almost certainly cut them out tomorrow.
Their major problem is that Facebook is an uneasy partner. Zygna make far more per-user than Facebook do and if they could, FB would almost certainly cut them out tomorrow.
I'd say it's fair compared to the rest of the market.
I think they had 200 million unique players, that puts profit-per-player at around $2/year. With 1500 employees it's ~$266,000 profit per employee per year. Very respectable, given that Google gets around $120,000/emp/year.
My big worry is that their profit margins return to industry average levels. There's plenty of reason to believe that they would earn closer to 5 or 10 percent vs. the ~%45 they currently get as time goes on. In that case, the company needs to grow to several billion dollars in revenue and become one of the largest game publishing companies in the world to support this valuation. I'm not entirely sure I see that happening for Zynga.
Even competition is going to struggle to bring down those profits, because of the same network effects Facebook now enjoys over competitors.
This is a market that is three years old, and massively susceptible to discontinuities - specifically newcomers and legal changes. I postulate that they will avoid paying dividends for at least a decade, perhaps throwing out a mangy 10% stock buyback (after issuing 11% in stock options to employees).
I am inclined to put on even more risk discount. Personally, I'd invest at a p/e of 4, maybe, but keep in mind that I don't really know what they do; so I suppose I will change that to a p/e of 3.2, and let's round it off to 3.