Dual Uprisings Show Potent New Threats to Arab States
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
On the whole though, these are positive signs. People in the Arab world are taking an active role in their governance. They are having discussions about the role of government and of liberty. They are being more and more exposed to reporting and information from other countries. Compared to the state of things a mere decade ago, this is a vast improvement.
I can't recall a single dictator in the modern history of the world which would fall down without US interference. People's engagement and activism is hard to undervalue and for sure the revolution is in their hands, but when I came across lots of such comments http://i.imgur.com/7u8xk.png I was really disappointed how people tend to easily forget history.
This is a case of a homegrown movement to overthrow a dictator. The resultant government is not necessarily what the West would prefer, but that is a consequence of being (rightly) seen as the funders and supporters of both the previous dictator and the instigators of the war waged by the next-door neighbor (Saddam Hussein's Iraq, whose military was entirely funded by Western powers and was once among the most powerful in the world).
The West was certainly not averse to selling weapons to the country, though neither was the Soviet bloc. During the 1980s the Iraqi air force was equipped mostly with French aircraft, and the army mostly with Soviet tanks, vehicles and weapons in addition to a smattering of weapons from other sources such as 100 G5 155mm howitzers from South Africa.
But it need not be said that selling weapons to a country is very different to funding its military.
http://www.iranchamber.com/history/articles/arming_iraq.php
It seems pretty well cited. That citation itself came from this Wikipedia article:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran–Iraq_War#U.S._support_for_...
As I mentioned before, the fact that Western countries and the Soviet bloc happily sold Iraq weapons and dual-use items during the 1980s is not in question. We know that happened, it has been public knowledge for quite some time.
Perhaps I'm being pedantic, but I feel that accuracy matters. There is a vast and important difference between directly funding a country's military and merely selling it weaponry.
Besides, if we're referring solely to the issue of arming Iraq, then the statement that Western countries were solely responsible for that is incorrect too. As I said before, most of the Iraqi army's equipment was purchased from the Soviets.
I believe you're being overly specific in your definition of what constitutes something more than mere partisanship. I think it's a reasonably safe statement that the war would likely not have happened without American blessings.
It is, of course, more complex because of the involvement of the Soviets, but I think in this case both the Soviets and the West wanted to contain Iran and both politically and materially encouraged Iraq to wage war.
All I've asked for is a citation for that claim. There really isn't much more to this than that.
If you are nitpicking over the use of my quantifier "entirely" I'll retract that. The evidence, though, is pretty clear:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_support_for_Iraq_...
Again, selling Iraq weaponry, turning a blind eye to its actions and providing it with intelligence information are all not the same thing as directly funding its military. This is really such a simple issue that I'm surprised it has gone on for this long.
* The "Iraqgate" scandal revealed that an Atlanta branch of Italy's largest bank, Banca Nazionale del Lavoro, relying heavily on U.S. government-guaranteed loans, funneled over US $5 billion to Iraq from 1985 to 1989.
* Saddam's elite troops received instruction in unconventional warfare at Fort Bragg
* The United States assisted Iraq through a military aid program known as "Bear Spares", whereby the U.S. military "made sure that spare parts and ammunition for Soviet or Soviet-style weaponry were available to countries which sought to reduce their dependence on the Soviets for defense needs."
Huh? You wrote "Saddam Hussein's Iraq, whose military was entirely funded by Western powers"
You've yet to provide any evidence supporting "entirely funded".
Yes, the US embargoed Iranian funds, but that's not the same as providing funds to Iraq. And neither is "the war wouldn't have happened without American blessings".
The fact that bad things happened does not support the claim that certain bad things happened.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_support_for_Iraq_...
The evidence for what "is pretty clear"?
Your reference says that some support was provided. It doesn't tell us how significant that support was given Hussein's other resources. (No "billions" isn't necessarily significant.)
As far as "nitpicking" goes, you wrote "entirely" to score political points. Why do you think that it's unreasonable to point out that you overstated that case and knew about it?
Feel free to assert that you'd give someone with whom you disagreed a pass if they'd done as you have.
I'm perfectly willing to believe that you "understood" Hussein to be "entirely funded". I'm even willing to believe that it is "common knowledge". Heck - I'm certain that one can even find "records" supporting that position.
The problem is that it appears to be false.
> Having had to look into it more to satisfy commenters here today has not revealed much evidence to the contrary.
Are you serious? You're going back to "entirely funded"?
Wowsers.
Lesson: huge props to the Egyptian people. But also give credit to the US administration. They didn't have to do what they did. Also, the follow-in issue being that probably the biggest reason why we had such strong leverage over Egypt was the billions in military aid we give them annually. To a government run by a dictator. Leverage is good, but backing dictators is bad in the long run, despite short term benefits.
Joining the bandwagon doesn't give them any more credence than the many other countries and people in the world demanding Mubarak to resign. They all deserve as much credit.
True, not necessarily. But likewise, speculation does not equal evidence. The actual evidence suggests that the US ultimatum to the Egyptian military was a strong force toward Mubarak stepping down, and it correlates more highly timeline-wise than the protestors actions. I could plot it on a graph and it would make it more apparent. Obviously the Egyptian military leadership also had a strong say in what happened. Many things probably had to be a certain way for things to happen like they did. But to imply that the actions of say, the government of New Zealand or Lichtenstein somehow played as strong a role and deserve as much credit as the the US government (or the Egyptian military leadership or the Egyptian protestors) I think is not reasonable based on the reality of it.
Giving billions to a dictatorship may be bad but it also gives the giving country a lot of political leverage when they want some kind of change on the receiving end. To somehow hand wave that away as not being significant is not realistic I think.
Since when the US doesn't have to join/start political changes in strategic regions? Let's wait what will be going on during the upcomming elections - US and EU have to an will take a big part in this game.
To a government run by a dictator. Leverage is good, but backing dictators is bad in the long run, despite short term benefits.
Oh, come on, a lot of dictatorships overthrown with US help where good buddies before.
We agree. I'm not sure why you think your statement contradicts what I said.
Externally, the American administration isn't really due any credit for Egypt's move towards democracy. However, from the American perspective, the fact that they didn't monumentally fuck up the entire situation somehow is something of a relief, on which we're unaccustomed to in recent years, and I think the administration at least deserves credit for that.