The design could use a little work, but I think it's far within the acceptable quality range. You said you didn't get much traction with this idea and having visited the site, I can at least tell you why it didn't work for me:
The idea of contacting my friends to leave feedback on why they think I'm awesome made me deeply uncomfortable. If it was the other way around, and you could post compliments to your friends, it might be different - but then you'd have to figure out how to solve the problem of spam control. To be fair, I'm not all that enchanted by the Three Words concept either. Sorry man, I wish I had more constructive things to say about this idea.