Which is why it perplexes me when tech people are so diversified with their holdings, there’s little opinion built in.
You have a competitive advantage. You see the tech tools that are utilized every day in your offices. You can understand neural networks and whether Tesla’s auto pilot OS technically reasonable.
You have the knowledge and skills to properly assess tech companies and their products.
You’re an insider in some respects.
Make an assessment, place your bets.
As a software engineer, I also tend to not invest in big tech companies. YMMV though.
Why avoid a Apple, etc?
Bigger risk, bigger returns. Oftentimes risk is opposite of the goal.
As long as you're aware of the interlinked nature of tech stocks in the tech industry, then by all means buy more, but if you're planning for retirement and you don't have a nest egg that's invested on lower risk with more modest returns, you might want to think twice about putting more eggs in the tech basket.
I work in a tech company. And almost everyone I know who works there is continually surprised at the stock price. They're surprised when it goes up when there's no seemingly good reason for it to do so, and they're equally surprised when it goes down.
While some may have the skill to analyze and predict, it's safe to say that most people - tech folks included - do not.
Likewise, a good understanding of the overall portfolio is key - and not just investments. For example, if you work at Tesla and hold mostly Tesla shares you are running an even higher risk than the average Tesla investor - the risk of you getting laid off is closely tied to Tesla shares tanking - and failing to diversify away that risk can hit many of us very, very hard.
It's not 100% because I don't compare against SPY the same exact time I bought the stock (too much work) and I don't bother calculating dividends. I just assume I am doing better there since I have a higher yield than SPY.
I do better than the market, but I don't recommend people trying to do so for money. I do it as a hobby, its fun for me. Otherwise a person's time is worth putting elsewhere, except in one area. While a person might not be able to beat the market, by being engaged they are more likely to invest more and avoid fruitless spending.
When someone spends 1000$+ on a handbag, I think gee, I'd rather have a share of google instead
The problem with people you describe is learning to do the other half of the company analysis.
There was recently post in HN "Tesla races past $100B in market valuation" : https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22118913 People gave good reasons why Tesla has good tech, good cars etc. None of those arguments were tied to price range. They would be just as valid for $100B, $500B or $1T valuations.
I think for technologists in particular expertise can be very dangerous as we tend to think we know a lot more than we do. Predicting the feasibility of an autopilot on a 1-2 year time horizon is a highly specialized difficult analysis. It's definitely not close to something most tech people can do well.
So if the majority of the group is that shocked by an incremental improvement, it would be better if we just interpreted their long-term forecasts as meaning "no idea" instead.
I could certainly pick out which tech companies are likely to succeed better than my grandma, but I'm not competing against her, I'm competing against professionals, and I simply don't have enough time to match someone who spends their entire day on it.
(Personally I favour diversifying with funds across countries and industries; plus a bet on a particular share, mostly tech for your reasoning, here and there.)
At the stage where tech companies aren't behemoths like that, they're waiting longer and longer to go public. Uber, the poster child for this generation of startup investing, waited until it was a $60B company before it went public. Maybe it's easy as a company to get private investment in the cases where my insider's expertise would help me.
My ability to see that full self driving wouldn't be here by 2020 and that Musk's timelines were hype-fueling B.S. doesn't help me with tesla stock, which went way up regardless.
I think netflix, as it currently exists, is on the way out. But that's a long term bet. Not only can the market stay irrational longer than I can stay solvent, netflix can make changes and turn shit around on that time scale. My informed opinions about the macbook don't help me predict the invention and success of the iphone.
Maybe I could use my expertise for investing if I made investing my full time job, but I have one already, and it probably pays better than whatever I'd earn gambling. What's a reasonably reliable amount to beat the market by in your mind? A few percent? Is a few percent worth giving up a $50k-200k/yr promotion by devoting those same efforts to getting better at my day job? Is a few percent worth investing in my industry so that my portfolio losing value becomes even more correlated to my home losing value and more correlated with losing my job?
Hell, when I vest stock at work, where I'm literally an insider, I immediately sell during open trading windows. It has exactly zero to do with how I feel about my company and everything to do with wanting to hedge my wealth and my employment against each other. A.k.a. diversification.
I just sat in a stand-up listening to my peers talking about making $20 or $60 on an Apple or Nvidia trade they made, and I'm like dudes you can make thousands in dividends a year and hardly look at your portfolio.
This is just straight naive, please do not bet on stocks based on your 'inside information.'
This is a strength, not a weakness. It protects against assumptions and biases in opinions.
> You have a competitive advantage. You see the tech tools that are utilized every day in your offices. You can understand neural networks and whether Tesla’s auto pilot OS technically reasonable.
The people I personally know in tech are mostly not located in sv and dont work with hot new shit. They are doing LOB programs for businesses. Smart people but i wouldn't be asking them about Neural Nets
> You’re an insider in some respects. Make an assessment, place your bets.
Most people really aren't
> Honestly, I think being "tech savvy" is a liability. Someone who doesn't think they're tech savvy knows they don't know. It takes a certain level of expertise to talk yourself into something extremely dumb.