Zappos has quietly backed away from holacracy
qz.com
qz.com
And the talked tackled the "R&D problem" by having R&D teams find a "sponsor" who would benefit from their eventual work. Really curious how it'll work out.
Do you end up with more efficiency by making every team compete in an internal marketplace and have to address customer needs to stay profitable? Or do teams find ways to carve out mini-monolopies and moats just like in the outside world and live off the fat of inefficiency.
Pros:
* R&D teams don't veer off into random tangents and are focused on delivering something useful
* More accountability and a closer connection to their end customer (internal or external)
Cons:
* you end up with more management layers and a lot more meetings to convince teams to fund you
* getting budget to maintain stuff is difficult to sponsor
* Empire building and a lot of infighting between competing teams
* product teams won't fund longer-term projects and moonshot experiments so you have to create a separate product team just for that
Of course, it's still fake money and there are a lot of overheads accounting for every little thing.
I derided it as reminiscent of soviet-style of management by collectives and committees.
The manager saw that in a bad light. Guess I lacked team spirit as it were.
Teal management ideas are absolutely at risk of the same problem.
I remember people pushing Teal in agile meetups a few years ago and all of those people would have been the alphas inside those communes.
Management helps protects the quiet types.