I don't really have a problem with it and it kicks the pants off an icon that didn't get that kind of workup in terms of visceral Polish, but as others have noted, it pretty much tells no story of the app at all. I'm not even interested enough to click on their header and learn.
That's fine though. Commodity design doesn't have to have an impact, and I prefer a world where commodity design is valuable and practiced over one where people just don't care.
Unity3D is a great example. Their logo isn't especially pretty, but it's iconic and it fits the product perfectly. And, it doesn't seem especially trendy, or dated — I guess that means it's timeless. http://unity3d.com/
It's pretty and it gives you a good idea what the product and company do.