Also keep in mind that all the panels we tested are much smaller than the ones oin those studies. This means that things like the frame, wires, connections become more important for embodied energy.
Also keep in mind that all the panels we tested are much smaller than the ones oin those studies. This means that things like the frame, wires, connections become more important for embodied energy.
I would love to see a life cycle assessment using wholly up-to-date numbers. I keep reading new studies on PV LCA, energy return on investment, and/or energy payback time. People who write these sorts of papers don't seem to keep up with what industry is actually doing. You can learn a lot from data sheets and trade publications. E.g. from published glass thickness and module size and efficiency, you can calculate the quantity of glass currently needed per watt-peak. It's significantly lower than any of these studies using decade+ outdated numbers.
I think part of the problem is one of incentives. Academics writing about LCA are often comparing some hoped-to-be-up-and-coming technology against the mainstream. Like thin film PV, organic PV, or dye sensitized cells pitted against crystalline silicon PV. In that case using old numbers for silicon PV helps the newer technology look like it offers exciting improvements.
Another problem is that reviewers apparently don't care very much about these temporal effects. They don't chase the citation chains to find the really outdated measurements cited in recently submitted manuscripts.
Another problem is that the solar industry has grown large and competitive. Cutting-edge numbers about energy consumption for silicon refinement are probably retained as a competitive advantage by the biggest producers, for example.
It's possible to set tighter upper bounds on resource intensity just from teardowns of recently manufactured modules. I suppose that teardown based analysis may itself be the sort of information you only get from specialty publications like the Photovoltaics International magazine, which is expensive and not indexed by DOI or part of ordinary academic libraries. (So it's not even in sci-hub.)
It's $599 a year if you want to be able to read back issues of Photovoltaics International from their archives:
https://store.pv-tech.org/photovoltaics-international/
I am interested enough in photovoltaic technology that I have bought a couple of $100+ specialty books from academic publishers, but $599 is a bit too steep even for me.
For the solar powered website article, it's the order of magnitude that matters. You say I overestimate the energy use of solar panel production, but in our configuration it corresponds to just 1 liter of oil per year.
If the numbers you were using were correct, then just the energy input for the solar panels would have cost more than the wholesale price for the modules.
For example, How do you account for the fact that all production facilities for solar panels have moved to China? If you look at the price evolution of solar panels, there's a gradual decrease due to technological progress (less energy use indeed). Then, from 2009 onwards, the decline in costs accelerates sharply, the consequence of moving almost the entire PV manufacturing industry from western countries to Asian countries, where labor and energy are cheaper and where environmental restrictions are more loose.
https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2015/04/how-sustainable-is...
But the costs of solar panels made in China in 2020 are much lower than those of solar panels made in China in 2010. Chinese factory wages have not fallen over the past 10 years, nor have Chinese pollution controls been further relaxed. The trend of falling costs over the last 10 years of made-in-China solar panels is due to improved techniques of production.
In 2010, Chinese producer Suntech was the largest PV manufacturer in the world. It sold 1.6 GW of panels and realized revenue of $2.9 billion:
https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/suntech-q4-earn...
Its panels were therefore selling for about $1.83 per watt in 2010.
Presently, Chinese high efficiency monocrystalline PERC panels are selling for no more than $0.25 per watt:
This 85% drop in prices indicates that technological and manufacturing progress in the solar sector continued at a rapid clip even after its center of gravity shifted to China.
You take the solar panel that just comes out of the factory as a reference, but I could just as well argue that the reference should be the age of the average solar panel installed in the world.
Also, let's wait and see how the move to China affects the quality and life expectancy of solar panels. And what it means for other forms of pollution. I focused on energy use but there are other environmental concerns with the production of solar panels.
I will be happy to update the calculations in the future if more and better data are available.
Depending on incentives and purpose one can choose which facts that one want to use. A fair comparison would be quite complex and have many variables one need to define for both the solar version and the power grid version.
The other approach compare the state of the art PV module vs the state of the art power plant, both being built using the latest mining and construction methods.
The answer of what is more sustainable is going to depend a lot on context. Are we comparing what a person can do right now, or what we should be doing in the future? For powering websites the general answer from the industry is currently to build data centers in depopulated areas in countries with cold climates, near a hydro power plant and with plenty access to cooling water. This is however not a solution that you can apply if the requirement is that the server must be located in Spain.