Hacker News Reader

Comment by mobilefriendly | Hacker News Reader

I live in the greater Washington DC metro area (Census-defined) and don't have internet access at my farm. No cable and no DSL available. I connect through a wireless 4G hotspot. This is really inadequate, my kids can't get online and we can't do any connected household stuff like Alexa or Ring. Our entire community is praying for Starlink!!!

View on HN

> my kids can't get online and we can't do any connected household stuff like Alexa or Ring

Any houses for sale nearby?

>my kids can't get online

Sometimes I'm not sure that's necessarily a bad thing?

It very obviously is. Homework assignments, keeping up with their friend groups, etc.

I don't agree. I grew up (partially) before DSL, as did everybody before Gen Z, and I'm very thankful for it. I don't think always on internet is necessary for a fulfilling childhood. There's so much more to the world than the internet.

It's not if society is generally structured around that, sure.

But if the only way to find out what your homework is is a website, and that homework is posted as a multimegabyte PDF (this is how it's working for my kids, not a hypothetical), then lack of an available internet connection immediately affects your ability to effectively attend school, for example.

Now we can have a discussion about whether school is necessary for a fulfilling childhood, of course. :)

Or more fundamentally, a discussion on whether pdf's on websites are necessary for school work?

Clearly not, if people are willing to hand out the same thing on paper. But they're not, for various reasons..

Reply on news.ycombinator.com