What would Union Square's performance have been if they just invested a max of once in each company? Twice? Instead of this N times strategy? I wonder the same about YC.
I think the strategy he's talk about is simply called Dollar Cost Averaging (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dollar_cost_averaging) in the public markets. I do it. It works and because there's data available it's easy to see.
I haven't seen anyone put out numbers yet on how important it is in angel/seed/VC investing.
My back of the envelope guess is that unless you follow this strategy (doubling down on your winners 3-5 times before liquidity) it's not worth it to do early stage investing, but I'm not sure. Would love to see some data.
Edit: Actually, looking up DCA its meaning is a bit more specific than I realized and not quite a strategy that I follow. I meant more about doubling down on your (expected) winners particularly when their price falls irrationally. Half-baked analogy.