Michael Lewis has a great episode about this in his podcast "Against the Rules". He actually gets a consultant to try to explain why CEOs are paid so much. The answers are pretty telling.
I'd love to check it out. Do you remember the episode title/consultant's name?
edit: I think it's "The Magic Shoebox" episode
I don't think it's that one, I think it's "The Hand of Leonardo". It convincingly links what happens in the art world with what happen with CEO compensation.