>> EE has always had a free registration at https://secure.experts-exchange.com/registerExpert.jsp . That people choose to not use it isn't EE's fault.
Your fault is hiding the link from users and sending them to https://secure.experts-exchange.com/register.jsp?rsid=60&... when clicking on the sign-up page. This kind of behavior is extremely offensive and hostile especially considering the fact that your users are from a demographic who can easily see through your BS.
>> EE's record, the last I saw, was seven SECONDS. I've seen at least a dozen under 20 seconds. Sometimes you get lucky.
With StackOverflow, I always get lucky. With EE, I have to get lucky to get a good answer (or even to see the answer behind all your paywall and ads).
>> You think voting helps you get the right answer; I think it's arrogant and rude that someone else tells you what works best for you.
WHAT? You ask a question because you want help and don't know what works for you. How is answering that question arrogant and rude? (Voting is also an special type of answering mechanism).
Sometimes the most voted answer may not solve your problem, but tell you that what you are trying to do is wrong. I think votes let you know which of the solutions to consider before trying out any of the solutions.
>> You think "everything should be free"; I think you charge for your services, and EE has every right to charge for its.
Except that you charge for the content your users created not knowing in advance that you guys will make it a closed system.
>> EE is successful because it only promises what it can provide, and keeps that promise.
EE was successful. You are not growing and will go down soon if you continue with your attitude: http://i.imgur.com/Vm1on.png
And what promise do you keep? I didn't know that providing different content to Google and to your visitors is your way of keeping promises.
>> When the $5 million in VC money runs out, then SO will have to get money from someone -- which means ads or a paywall.
All of SO content is in CC license. If they go rogue, the community will just create a new website with the same content.
Basically all this boils down to what kind of people run the site. I am sorry that the people behind EE cannot see the future.
[1] http://blog.williamhilsum.com/2011/02/response-to-experts-ex...