What So Many People Don’t Get About the U.S. Working Class
hbr.org
hbr.org
One particular subject that this article mentions, and that I didn't initially agree with until I read one of Yang's books - is the notion that human labor markets are actually very inelastic, and don't self correct easily. People choose jobs for reasons that are often based on identity, not on economics. I may not agree with this particular author's point on masculinity being why Hillary lost - I do agree that is the root cause for many working men not taking pink collar jobs even if desperate. The reverse happens too - many women would never work construction or truck driving even if it pays well. With that in mind, it is fundamentally much easier to craft policy that provides alternative jobs and income opportunities than it is to change a person's sense of identity or society's sense of masculinity. So again, it comes back to economic policy (like UBI) needng to be front and center.
One last thing - many working class people are enterprising and do want to start businesses, even if that's impractical. Min wage increases and paid time off don't help you do that, and they also dont mean anything for people who work gig jobs / contract to pay the bills. So while UBI isn't perfect, it does appeal to that aspirational element more than other left economic policies.
Not sure how getting government handouts squares with people that want to do “manly work”
And the masculinity thing was mostly in regards to why retraining attempts frequently fail even if there is demand.
He said this recently, and though it's overly simplistic - I think it does kinda capture the resistance that people do have to changing their ideas of themselves and their work dramatically.
> “I was just at a truck stop in Iowa,” Andrew Yang says on Fox. He says if you told those truckers you were going to retrain them to be computer programmers, they “would be more likely to punch you in the face than to sign up.”
Two anecdotes. One was a comment by an architect mentioning his father's rage when he told him he was going to college to be an architect instead of following his brothers into the shipyards.
The other was when I was a kid some of the other little kids would try to tease me and my brother with the refrain 'your dads a secretary because he works in the office'. Meaning their dad's were manly machinists working at FMC and Lockheed. And my dad was pantywaist engineer working in the office.
Hah. How is HRC royally screwing up multiple times in the national spotlight and her losing as a result "unfair"?
> The election shows that sexism retains a deeper hold than most imagined.
Citation needed. This argument is as tiring and boring as the Russian conspiracy theory
Not quite accurate.
The exact quote is:
"You know, to just be grossly generalistic, you could put half of Trump's supporters into what I call the basket of deplorables. (Laughter/applause) Right? (Laughter/applause) They're racist, sexist, homophobic, xenophobic – Islamophobic – you name it."
While "half" might be an exaggeration, I don't think she's generally wrong. Patriot Prayer, Proud Boys, all these other white supremacy groups, they're all right-wing and love Trump.
Voting for Hillary is not palatable to those people.
I don't. I just disagree with what "change" they need. It's pretty silly to think that a rich corporate CEO and reality TV star would have the best interests of blue collar workers in mind. He preyed on their prejudices to earn votes.
I grew up surrounded by these people, and I miss them. They were crusty and had many problems, but they were also the salt of the earth in a way hard to imagine these days. Mostly blue-collar Democrats. Picture Mike Rowe's show maybe.
One in our neighborhood, who lived on a main road, would regularly invite hobos (homeless, for you kids) to their family dinner table, feed them a hot meal, and send them on their way. Not particularly from some religious motivation. Rather, it was more like "We're all Americans, and we stick up for each other". That's an ethos, a feeling, that we all (and Democrats in particular) need to recapture, in my opinion.
When you say Democrats, do you mean voters and/or politicians? Why do you think they don't, in particular, stick up for Americans?
>Otto just delivered the first self-driving truck shipment. In a few short years, the most common job in what was it, 30 or so states? It'll be all but gone.