Location is also extremely important. For instance, I can't handle living and working in the SV or Seattle areas, so any offers that require me to do that are automatically out.
Pay is important, but not a critical factor. I have a floor below which I won't go, but (fortunately) that floor is much lower than my value to employers -- so I can generally ignore pay issues, or use pay as a bargaining chip to get something else that I want more.
I'll also want to get a chance to walk through the offices and observe the other engineers working there. If they seem generally unhappy or overly stressed, then I'll turn the offer down.