OTOH, if you were to argue that it's not your device, or that you weren't the person that encrypted it, that's a very different situation.
This ruling only says that the confinement period for contempt of court, where the court has order an individual to de-encrypt some data, is too long if it is more than 18 continuous months. This does not mean that after serving that sentence and upon subsequent release, that further refusal after another court order and hearing can not result in another sentence for contempt.
OTOH, if a witness forgets, they would not be held in court, because there's no benefit to them forgetting, and so their loss of memory is believable.
Try to think about it from the court's point of view. The truth could be:
A. You legitimately forgot.
B. You're lying.
I know which one Occam's Razor favors.
B. You're guilty.
Uh, this is the essential question to begin with. The judge doesn't decide this unless you're in clown court.
I do understand the meaning and most likely intent of your post, but the language used is less effective than it could be.
You don't want to go into any of those reasons people waive a jury, right?
Yeah, I'd bet that most people claiming to have forgotten a key or password are lying. But so what? How do you differentiate those who're concealing vs. those that legitimately don't know the string of characters? If they float, they're a witch, if they sink, then I guess they're not? (That's what 18 months for contempt is akin to)