I hate surveillance as much as anyone, but it's hard to see how it might be a good thing that someone's website launch is being censored by the state.
If you cant meet basics of compliance, dont be surprised that your website that is a giant trove of personal information is regulated.
If your business has something that causes externalities and you dont pay for them, the government is going to(hopefully!) regulate you from screwing the rest of us over, or selling dangerous products to consumers for cheaper because of "choice".
If you claim that choice is impacted and that's a bad thing you actually need to prove the counter claim - that the activity you are doing is SO IMPORTANT to us as a society its worth going around our standard operating procedures.
To me that sounds like a nightmarish world to live in, one in which you have no rights except what others choose to grant you. What about the principle of innocent until proven guilty? The burden of proof should be on the accusers claiming harm, otherwise we might as well just completely stop advancing as a species, because anything we change could possibly harm someone in some unspecified way.
Doesn't apply to Facebook. They've repeatedly shown themselves to be guilty.
No, it's not benign even if "no one died".
Top 5 sorted by fine (from https://www.enforcementtracker.com/):
- British Airways
- Marriot
- TIM (Italian communications provider)
- Austrian Post
Doesn't really look like "beef with US tech companies" to me.
Most companies elsewhere are used to being taxed and regulated.
Got it.
Data protection laws have been in place in Europe for way longer than GDPR. They all basically say this: you must protect private and personally identifiable data of people.
Nearly every single tech company did nothing to protect that data. Especially the international behemoths like Facebook.
Then the EU unified the different data protection laws into a single one: GDPR. And said: up until now we were lax in protecting out citizens' rights. We're gonna stop doing that now.
logicchains on HN: oh my god, how can you even think of enforcing this against a poor company who offers users choice.
The same company that sells private data wholesale, tracks users even if they are not present on the site, regularly breaches privacy laws, explicitly targeted teenagers for behavioural research, prevents users from permanently removing records from the service, retains data on a people even after removal from service, exposes private and sensitive data to thousands of advertisers, tracks users' locations despite opt-out, aggregates users' health data without their consent, lobbies against privacy protections, etc. etc. etc.
Yes. That's exactly why GDPR exists and exactly why FB must comply with it.
I hate cancer as much as anyone, but it’s hard to see how it might be a good thing that someone’s tobacco advertising is being censored by the state.
I hate sex trafficking as much as anyone, but it’s hard to see how it might be a good thing that someone’s Russian bride catalog launch is being censored by the state.
——
I guess my point is that your broad objection to government interference is completely meritless without considering the specific harms and benefits under discussion. The problem with surveillance is that the harms are distributed and delayed. Meanwhile Facebook does everything it can to obfuscate what these harms might even be.
The harms of regulation are also distributed and delayed. The Backpage.com sex workers who were selling their services online have to go back to the danger of working the streets as a consequence of new online sex trafficing laws. People previously buying drugs safely online now have to go back to the streets, with dangerous dealers and worse infrastructure for testing drug safety. GDP grows a little slower, nobody notices for a while, until a couple decades later the standards of living in that country are lower than their neighbours and what they could have otherwise been. Some people miss out on meeting the love of their life who they might otherwise have met on Facebook Dating.
It's not enough to consider the benefits and harms of the thing you're considering banning, you also need to consider the harms of the ban itself, and of creating the political infrastructure to enforce the ban, that could be turned against you the moment a far-right government wins an election (may I remind you that the People's National Front won 33% of the vote at the last French election).
Social harm: nothing.
The implication that any government ban is bad, because fascists, is silly. The concept that some bans have net negative consequences is fine, but there is nothing to suggest that is the case here.
I don't know what the answer is, because I hate the idea of limiting the rights of those who are competent and responsible in order to protect those who are not.