"I am not convinced that trading users privacy for any sort of latest and greatest tech necessarily sets you back. This might be true, but it's not a given"
True, but why on earth is the government deciding on your behalf what this trade-off is?
It's the government's job to make sure the trade-off is apparent, within reason, and then let people decide for themselves.
For example, I don't want to be on Facebook ... so my magical solution is that I don't use it.