Hacker News Reader

Comment by progval | Hacker News Reader

> which is the only(?) function in the language that has an optional parameter before a required one.

The documentation shows it as being overloaded, rather than having default arguments:

    range(stop) -> range object
    range(start, stop[, step]) -> range object

There's iter which is overloaded:

    iter(iterable) -> iterator
    iter(callable, sentinel) -> iterator

View on HN

That's the thing - it's documented as overloaded, because that's the most intuitive explanation. Wren would allow it to actually be implemented as an overloaded function.

Python doesn't support overloading, and it doesn't support optional arguments before required ones, so the actual implementation in Python is a bit messy - something like:

  def range(start_or_stop, optional_stop=None):
      if optional_stop is None:
          start = 0
          stop = start_or_stop
      else:
          start = start_or_stop
          stop = optional_stop
      ...

there is no optional positional in the implementation. range is overloaded in the raw sense of the term as the implementation checks the number of arguments and their types and does the right thing.

it could have been implemented in pure python as well by doing args, *kwargs.

Well, however the `range` function is implemented, IMO its API would be better expressed as true overloading - as two functions with the same name.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com