Hacker News Reader

Comment by IridiumFX | Hacker News Reader

that is brilliant: Apple Music has ads about the Apple music service. Apple Arcade about the arcade service. The App store about App store deals. Apple Card about the Apple Card product. Ok, note taken.

Now checking my android phone, main screen just there on the top ... oh hey google in a multicolor G ...

yes they both qualify as adaware. The difference seems that the Apple approach is at least context-aware. You don't get random ads or suggestions system-wide. You get ... newspaper ads in the newspaper app, or music ads in the music app.

I honestly wish we had the same on the android front. Google is decidedly much more invasive these days

View on HN

The only thing that I found suspect about Apple's behavior has to do with the push notifications. But even then, it does seems like you can turn them off.

From the Article: "If you subscribe and then cancel, Apple sends invasive push notifications asking you to re-susbscribe. These are on by default without a permission request. This is, of course, against the rules they lay out for other developers."

Apple Rules: Push Notifications must not be required for the app to function, and should not be used for advertising, promotions, or direct marketing purposes or to send sensitive personal or confidential information.

I mean, I just uninstalled my Apple Music app..

Yeah, this is what I don't get. Nowadays you can just uninstall any Apple app you're not using so I don't see why the big fuss?

As far as I know, if you want to be able to sync music from your computer or use a third-party, non-steaming music app you must have Apple Music installed as well.

Indeed, at least the “ads” in Apple’s apps have a chance at being useful. If you don’t use the app or don’t want to see the ads, remove the app and install your preferred alternative… boom. Done. You won’t be bothered again.

I don’t know I see the issue here unless Apple is supposed to abstain from taking a piece of the services pie, because how weird would it be if they offered services but didn’t mention it in iOS at all?

And if you use neither of the mentioned apps you get no ads. At least in my experience.

They do have two invasive notifications that they should fucking tone down though:

1. Prompts to upgrade your OS. I once got one while i was driving and using the phone as GPS, and I pressed the wrong button (because I was paying attention to the road, duh) so I had to pull in the next parking area and wait for the OS upgrade to finish. This is major assholery, Apple.

2. Prompts to set up 2FA. No, I won't enable that because I don't carry all my Apple devices with me and what use is a 2FA code on my tablet that I left home when I'm a few hundred km away on a weekend trip?

And since I'm whining, I'd like the option to use the pass code / face recognition only to authentificate Apple Pay payments, not for the whole phone.

The google logo counts as an ad for you? Or does google actually show ads on stock-android?

The Google logo instead of a plain search bar is an ad. Imagine if your browser had one in the URL bar: it'd be ridiculous, and very annoying!

Well, it searches google, doesn’t it? I’m not trying to be argumentative, I really don’t know, haven’t run what’s preinstalled since day 3 of my very first Android phone. I know Firefox shows me the DuckDuckGo logo when I enter a search term, so it seems reasonable to me.

edit:

> Imagine if your browser had one in the URL bar: it'd be ridiculous, and very annoying!

Just checked, Chrome does that, I guess that was your point ;)

Is there such a thing as stock Android?

Anecdotically, I have an Android phone that I use for development (i.e. it sits on my desk most of the time). Every time I turn it on I get notifications that I have updates available or something has been updated or whatever - with the google logo - that I cannot disable anywhere.

I also get some of those from manufacturer supplied "helpful crap" but I suppose we can't blame Google for those...

By stock I meant OEM. People on XDA call the OEM image stock.

In that case the "stock" Android is full of spam. From Google and from the manufacturer.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com