Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by guessmyname | Hacker News Reader

Full thread

guessmyname

I have been using the macOS menu bar application for a while [1].

There used to be a page [2] linking to it, but it seems they deleted it.

Surprisingly, the app is fully native [3] and that’s why I keep it around.

Here is a screenshot [4] in case anyone is curious to see how it looks.

[1] https://s3-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/poolside-fm/HeyThereHotSt...

[2] https://poolside.fm/mac/

[3] https://pastebin.com/raw/9j45WN00

[4] https://i.imgur.com/k0Ahk6h.png

View on HN

I had some issues with that a few years ago and wrote my own version in PyQt (it’s basically just a shuffled stream of their SoundCloud playlist). Never managed to polish it enough to publish though... maybe I should rewrite it in Go and release it.

Downloaded it, but it asked for permission to use MacOS' accessibility features, which I thought was weird.

But they mention iOS and mac apps on the site coming soon and have an email signup form.

A lot of non-accessibility apps use the accessibility features to do things like window resizing and clipboard management. Looking at my relatively pristine MacBook Pro's settings, I've got Flycut and Rectangle (expected) and less expectedly Dropbox and Aquamacs with accessibility access.

I think (but could be wrong) that it's a relatively low-risk permission to grant.

It’s a risky permission. It allows the app to read keystrokes and manipulate other apps as though they were receiving input from the user.

Agreed. Accessibility permission gives pretty much root access, since you can click anything and give yourself any other permissions.

I totally understand why certain apps need it, but not a simple music player.

Even "simple apps" can improve their UX with it like a translator app that you can summon with a global keybinding.

There just seems to be lack a convention around telling the user why the app might need those privs. Users don't even know what accessibility privs do.

the mac link doesn't work (anymore?)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com