The problem with that tradeoff nowadays is that in many cases you're just barely breaking even or coming out ahead with what a FAANG can pay even if the startup is wildly successful. The only way that tradeoff will start being worth it again is if founders and VCs give more real equity to employees so they can benefit if the start up is wildly successful.
Once I was told, well, we want to give you a raise of X% of your base salary, but money is tight. So here's X-5%, and 5% in stock options. Not stock, options.
So, not only do we have to go public, but we also have to double (triple really, because you know I didn't get that 5% as cash the second year) for me to get the raise you say I deserve. Plus, in order to exercise those options to get compensated, I have to pay you that 5% in cash. Super.
Honestly, and along the lines of another responder, a big raise is never as sweet as a modest raise and a little autonomy. If money is tight, a little raise and a little more autonomy can smooth things over pretty well.
It's a nice benefit, and it'd be cool to see something similar in tech.
If it doubles in a year, I'm now earning $400k in equity a year for next 3 years rather than $200k. (I recall my investment)
If it dies after a year, I only lost $200k, not the entire $700k.