Agreed, if it is their profession they know it better. The thing I was initially refering to is stuff like people who do a horrible layout in word and ask to to literally do the same thing without having any qualification on the matter. Or people who want you to put a whole page of text nobody will ever be able to read onto a roadside sign.
This feels like if one would ask a electrician to use wires without insulation because they like them better — you can totally have your taste, but some stuff is just plain stupid and won't work as intended.
Graphics e.g. is about communicating certain things, and a graphic designers job is to be aware of what this communication does and how effective it does it. And so just like with a bridge (but arguably less dangerous) there can be design that does the job and design that does the polar oposite of what your customer intended.