I hope Prager appeals, this could easily reach the SC and potentially be an even more influential case than Marsh.
I hope Prager appeals, this could easily reach the SC and potentially be an even more influential case than Marsh.
Or as pointed out in the article, probably not:
> Appeals court judges were not convinced. They pointed to a Supreme Court case[1] from last year in which plaintiffs unsuccessfully "tested a theory that resembled PragerU's approach, claiming that a private entity becomes a state actor through its 'operation' of the private property as 'a public forum for speech.'" The case involved public access channels on a cable TV system.
[1] https://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/manhattan-commun...
Interestingly Manhattan Community Access Corp is definitely in some regards closer to a state actor, being authorized by NYC to operate.
If they can't convince that level of hack, they don't have a chance in the SC.