Removing verification from people who violate TOS or spread messages that Twitter does not want to endorse is deliberate but unrelated.
Removing verification from people who violate TOS or spread messages that Twitter does not want to endorse is deliberate but unrelated.
One which means “we sanction this person/their twitter persona” and another which means, “this twitter persona belongs to or is controlled by the person who it claims to be.”
We don’t need this muddled confusing system.
They are deliberately keeping the verification mark vague, so that people "misunderstand" it and so Twitter can claim publically that they aren't really endorsing anyone (but remove the mark from people they don't want to endorse).
If they believe the person has violated their policies, then they should just ban them. If they don't want them having a blue checkmark when the ban expires, then they should ban them for life. Leaving them in this weird limbo without a blue checkmark turns it into something more like "Twitter's badge of approval", and feels petty and vaguely dystopian. I think it should just be "Twitter's badge of this-account-is-not-an-impersonator".
As another poster said, if they truly insist on this badge of approval, then they should have two checkmarks: one for verification, and one for "we consider this person a respectable, trustworthy, and upstanding member of the Twitter community" or whatever.
But then, Twitter realised it could make money from the increased engagement blue check marked accounts generate. So it became exclusive. And then when they realised they'd be publicly/socially liable when celebrities said things Twitter the company didn't like, Twitter threatened removal of the check mark. So the check mark became Twitters stamp of approval to use, and be popular on, their platform.
The blue check mark should only ever have been a way to say "the name and identity I claim to have on their profile has been verified". That should be open to Leonardo DeCaprio, and John Smith down the street.
No. A publisher can have biases. You would not appreciate any utility changing your service because of biases.
To me, it highlights how incumbent social media companies are easy targets for manipulation. They were never designed to disseminate truths; they were designed to amplify parrots and promote their own growth by capitalizing on trends like "going viral".