I see only monopolies.
I see only monopolies.
But the vast majority of companies aren't of that disruptive kind. They're just normal mom and pop shops, and FBA/Shopify businesses.
Pretty much all those monopolies support small business. Think of Google, Facebook, YouTube, Etsy, Yelp, etc.
Also, I'd push back on the implication that cut-throat competition leads to innovation. I think that's rarely the case. It absolutely leads to incremental innovation but rarely to disruptive innovation.
That is almost always a function of an outsider, who's willing to challenge existing assumptions. (More often than not out of sheer ignorance of the existence of those assumptions. I can't even count the number of founders who've told me something along the lines of 'We didn't know we weren't supposed to do it this way.' Or, 'Had we known it would've been so hard, we'd have never even started.'
Citizen science is cool, but doesn't extend outside of incremental value add domains. Fusion and more will almost certainly be from monopolies or monopolistic competitors.
At least that's how I interpreted that comment.
But Xerox PARC immediately came to mind, which was a breeding ground of innovation.
The capacitive touch screen was invented by Bent Stumpe at CERN [1]. The software technology that arguably made the iPhone possible, multi-touch, was developed by U of T, Bell Labs, and CMU. Steve Jobs visited CMU in 1985, though that obviously didn't translate into much back then.
The actual multi-touch software that went into the iPhone was developed by FingerWorks founders John Elias and Wayne Westerman at the University of Delaware [2]. Apple bought FingerWorks and incorporated the technology into the iPhone.
I had a product idea recently, researched it, and found a couple Chinese type products that did what my idea would do on paper...
One was priced at 6$, another, $15.99. The problem is, they'll all set your house on fire. No isolation, bad circuit design, globs solder everywhere, not rated for the right amperage.
A proper design would probably cost $75 for the consumer.
People assumed consumers wanted a cheap vacuum. (That's not an unreasonable assumption.) Dyson then showed that there are other dimensions consumers are willing to judge a vacuum on than just price alone.
One category (out of 4) in Pragmatic Behavioral Psychology (or Dutch School of Marketing) is context changing. By creating a $75 product, consumers have nothing to compare it too and might judge solely on price if they view it as a commodity.
Should you use context changing, you can shift the conversation from price to safety by educating them. Perhaps throwing it in the shape of a story about a couple who's house burned down, and why it's so important not to think you can skimp on this stuff.
In that context, you're no longer competing on price but on quality because you've messed with the context frame.
These are all things that will need to be tested. The only way to know for certain is by talking to users and seeing if you can sell the product.