These workers belonged to a union
The union did not endorse the strike
The strike occured during a period of operation under an agreed-upon contract
Re-opening the contract for negotiation would have lead to renegotiating for 90,000 other employees during a school year
The workers were withholding student grades, harming others who have taken out a significant bet against their own futures that they would get good grades and eventually jobs to repay that financial aid
There are a number of ways this could have played out, and was basically the second-to-worst case scenario. I am sympathetic to those working under an oppressive union and university, but there really wasn't going to be a different outcome given the path they took.
"We are shocked by UC's callousness, and by the violence that so many protesters experienced as they peacefully made the case for a cost of living increase," said Kavitha Iyengar, president of UAW Local 2865, in a statement. "Instead of firing TAs who are standing up for a decent standard of living for themselves, UC must sit down at the bargaining table and negotiate a cost of living increase."
Last week, the university filed an unfair labor practice charge against the union, claiming the union has failed to stop the wildcat strike by the graduate students as it is required to do by the collective bargaining agreement.
The union responded by filing its own unfair labor practice charge, alleging the university has refused to meet with the union to negotiate a cost of living adjustment.
Direct from the article. Care to back up your statement?
"The strike, which is not authorized by the union that represents the graduate student employees, is in violation of the current bargaining agreement, the university said."
It's not clear that the union authorized it, despite what they're quoted as saying further down the article.
I don't know enough about unions to know whether they could authorize a strike after not explicitly authorizing initially.
It reads like the union didn't authorize the strike, but was fine seeing what would happen/causing a reaction.
In practice, union bureaucrats really dislike wildcat strikes. They dissipate the negotiating power of the union; they basically show the entire hand of the union's most powerful weapon, at a time the union views as suboptimal. And it's usually the threat of a strike, not the strike itself, that companies are more scared of: a company highy desires to avoid a disruption, but if it's already in progress, they don't have an incentive to negotiate unless the union has a really strong hand.
I'm not cheering their firing. I'm just explaining why their strike did not work out as they wished.
> ask for compensation that reflects the value they bring to the organization
That's not how it works in the real world. You get paid by market rate; which means if there is someone else accepting a pay cut, you'll get fired and replaced.
> Universities are no different to businesses in this respect
Universities are a competitive business, too; and students pay high tuition fees. If the universities are out-competed, they can lose business/students. It's turtles all the way down.
I agree, that's true. It's almost as if this is an unjust system that devolves into a race to the bottom and inevitable exploitation of workers. And that in the real world, anyone who tries to fight against this system ends up screwed by their employers.
I'm glad we could agree on the exploitation inherent to the labor market.
When you hire a plumber to do some work on your plumbing, do you do any price comparisons? If so, do you feel that’s “exploitation”?
Yet this system has increased the real pay of labor many, many fold over the past 100 years, to where even poverty level in the US is above a good portion of the world income, even though those other people also labor quite hard.
It's an odd race to the bottom that has raised wages so significantly for all quintiles.
I love how people dismiss injustice with an appeal to "the market" as if the market was a force of nature rather than a manmade and human manipulated entity.
Markets are created by a handful of people and affected by laws. And supply and demand is also an man-made creation. For example, by creating laws allowing seasonal migrants, you could affect the wages of farm workers. The same thing with work visas like H1-B. Also, laws favoring employers' rights and workers' rights can also affect wages. And of course "credentialing" and artificially limiting supply in the case of doctors affects wages.
> Universities are a competitive business, too;
Not really. Pretty much all the top universities stay at the top because of legacy. Also UC Santa Cruz is a public university. Very little chance it is going to be out-competed and put out of business.
Where do you think UC as a public institution would be if it lost political support of the faction allied with organized labor? It already doesn't have support from the opposing faction.
Relatively little of the funding for the UC's comes from the state. Tuition is a much larger percentage. So they do have a concern of being out-competed.
https://www.dailycal.org/2018/08/08/2018-uc-accountability-r...
The market is an emergency force. It isn't determined by a secret cabal of evil capitalists. It may not be a "force of nature" (although that is debatable because it is a direct consequence of natural properties like scarcity), but that doesn't mean it can be simply up and changed.
>Markets are created by a handful of people and affected by laws
I bake a bunch of bread. You grow a bunch of potatoes. We are both willing to trade. That's a market. All people participate in the market if they consume goods and/or offer labor.
Maybe the protests and the media coverage are an important part of spreading information and correcting the demand problem for academic positions. We need to tell the world that academia is not what it is presented as.
Your position is akin to opposing online restuarant reviews because why put reviews online if the market will put bad restaurants out of business..
Do you mean emergent force?
> It isn't determined by a secret cabal of evil capitalists.
Capitalists? Socialists, communists, monarchs, mercantilists, etc also use laws to create and manipulate "the market". The US, China, Saudi Arabia, North Korea, EU, etc all create markets. Not all of them are a cabal of evil capitalists. I was talking about markets, not capitalism. Markets exist with or without capitalism. Two people could just form a market as you noted below.
> although that is debatable because it is a direct consequence of natural properties like scarcity
You can force scarcity through laws as well. Coal, fishing, diamonds, etc being examples.
> but that doesn't mean it can be simply up and changed.
It sure as hell can influence it. Which was my point.
> I bake a bunch of bread. You grow a bunch of potatoes. We are both willing to trade. That's a market.
In other words "a manmade and human manipulated entity".
Just because a "cabal of evil capitalists" doesn't say a doctor should make $100,000 doesn't mean that the "market" isn't manmade and manipulated. We could relax laws and allow a flood of doctors from around the world and I suspect doctors' wages would decline. You get the idea?
The market is no more an "emergent force" than the rules of monopoly are an emergent force. No more than cities, governments, etc are emergent forces. They are all man-made structures with levels of human manipulation.
Workers are treated as replaceable when they are in fact easily replaced. Grad students aren't even really workers, though. They're students where teaching responsibilities are part of their professional training, and as with most similar positions (apprenticeships and internships), they aren't especially lucrative and there's a line around the block to replace anyone who quits.
"As part of its commitment to transparency and public accountability, each year the University of California publicly reports employee pay data. The report covers UC's career faculty and staff employees, as well as part-time, temporary and student employees." [1]
I think the commonly accepted definition of worker is someone who is an employee and not a manager. Grad students are pretty clearly employees, according to the UC system.
As a grad student, I taught 2 undergraduate courses a semester as the professor, the same load as a full faculty member—very much ‘workers in the traditional sense.’ Moreover, grad students are also writing a dissertation and doing research for their advisors and taking a full course load, and apparently in CA, also working a side job to pay their bills.
[1] There are two exceptions to the rule that interns don't get paid much: professional services and engineering. Both fields use internships almost exclusively as a recruiting tool and don't claim to provide any educational value.