> I did not say that anyone did try to extrapolate numbers using these percentages in this thread.
But you did imply that. Look, I am all for keeping a cool head. But at the same time I'm not going to cool my head by sticking it in the sand. I think if you're going to participate in these discussions then you probably should do so by making your statements a lot clearer than you do.
If you - for instance - idd not intend to suggest that someone did try to extrapolate those numbers then you did a poor job of it. You can't just make up strawmen and then suggest people shouldn't do that.
The comment you linked to was properly qualified and is not fearmongering. If you think that is fearmongering then you possibly have a reading / comprehension issue.
Let me help you by picking that comment apart:
> The 1.4% apply to the general population.
You can't really argue with that I think,
> For people over 80, the fatality rate is 15%.
Not exactly correct, I have it at 14.8% once infected and showing symptoms. But close enough.
> There are roughly 13 million people over 80 in the US [1].
This is properly cited.
> If everyone gets infected, a fatality rate of 15% means 2 million deaths in that single bracket alone.
Again, this is properly qualified by the leading 'If'
> With the 1.4% figure it's 4.6 million over the entire US population.
Again, with the implied assumption that people are all infected, something that is unlikely to happen.
> As a comparison, the number of yearly deaths in the US caused by influenza is in the 5 digits.
This is correct as far as I know, between 10 and 60K cases annually ranging from very good years to very bad ones.
> World war 2 killed 3% of the world population over a range of multiple years [2].
Can't argue with that.
> If the coronavirus kills only 1% of the current world population, its death toll in absolute numbers will be equal to WW2.
Again, properly qualified by a conditional.
> I think at this point, the disease can't be contained, its spread only slowed.
I don't think anybody is arguing that it can be contained still, even the WHO has moved on this, though they kept it up for longer than I personally think was responsible.
> Everyone will be exposed to it sooner or later.
Probably correct, similar to the flu, most people get exposed to it in their lives and usually once per year.
> Fortunately though there are treatments, and there are already candidates for vaccines. The question is only how quickly and how well those treatments can be deployed.
If there is one part of this comment that I have issues with then it is this one. There are - as far as I know - no vaccine candidates that have been trialed. I'm happy to be proven wrong here so any link is welcome.
> The less people have the disease at the same time, the better.
And that is the key insight: the whole thing revolves around managing the capacity to deal with the people that are ill. That and effectively reducing R0 < 1 are the main tools that we have at this stage to deal with this particular virus.