Lyle's (science) problem is that he runs with every new paper, ignoring the fact that it directly contradicts the paper he touted last year.
21 years ago (I mean this literally, I read him then) he was touting on MFW how the discovery of leptin was going to render dieting obsolete in less than a decade.
He has a lot of good content, but it's always decisive, even when some is rong.