Inflicting "stack ranking" upon the world, for one.
Not all contributions are positive.
Inflicting "stack ranking" upon the world, for one.
Not all contributions are positive.
During the stack ranking heyday there was a manager who spent his year compiling a list of mistakes by other teams. When it came to year end reviews anyone asking about the ranking of this manager's people ended up deflected with questions about their own team members. People learned to just leave this manager's rankings alone and work around him. He was wildly successful, getting promoted early and often before leaving the company to go start a recruiting firm which allegedly applies some sort of AI principles to picking good candidates.
For details on the daily workings of stack ranking at Microsoft, the venerated Mini Microsoft is still up and available in all it's 15 year old glory. It's one of the true documents of contemporary tech work, and I'm glad it isn't just buried in archive.org (long live archive.org).
Go back to the first couple years and you'll be soaking in it.
The real failure of stack ranking is it never ends, so at some point you are firing good employees.
Stack ranking is stupid, heartless and unscientific. Just like the man who invented it.