Edit: Would "instagramsucks.com" or "facebooksucks.com" also be infringing?
Edit: Would "instagramsucks.com" or "facebooksucks.com" also be infringing?
And in terms of trademark law the owners are unlikely to be on stronger grounds if they're not a pure phishing operation as alleged, but have merely chosen to include Facebook's trademark in their website or email marketing name without Facebook's permission to increase the likelihood Facebook's customers will purchase services from them.
You don't have to imply you definitely are the owner of a trademark to fall foul of trademark law, you just have to be trying to profit from using the trademark without permission in their line of trade in a way you can't justify as 'fair use'. I think we can rule out the idea instagrambusinesshelp.com is commentary, comparison, parody or a list of third parties worked with.
I'm not disputing that the sites themselves are scammy/phishing, but what Facebook is saying here sounds like an overreach that amounts to "using Facebook trademarked names in a domain name is misleading and inherently untrustworthy".
My company also has a business portal. Can I take down domains that are similar to it as well? Or is this power just reserved for MegaCorp Inc. who can afford large legal teams? At what point does a company become large enough to warrant "protection" of domains similar to their own? Who makes that decision and is there any dispute process? Etc, etc...
So many questions and potential pitfalls surrounding this approach. I don't know if there's any better realistic "solution" than to let users ultimately be responsible for the domains they visit. Not much of a solution but I don't see any better options that are both realistic and helpful.
The big drawback of the process it that it doesn't work well for phishing attacks, where taking down one domain is of limited value. It's designed more for things like nissan.com
Do I also have the right to impose rules on other businesses naming conventions [1], or no because I'm not a $500B company?
[1] In a fair use context, not blatant copyright/trademark infringement or posing as the company in a phishing context.