But as a driver, our resentment for bike commuters doesn't just come from entitlement (though somewhat, yes). It comes from fear, just like yours. I really don't want to accidentally kill anyone, and bikers are one of the only encounters in my daily life when I feel like that might happen.
I wish it were safer for bikers. Our infrastructure is terrible. The bike lanes are spotty and bad when they exist. Lane separation is more symbolic than physical.
I get that bikers want to be on the road anyway, and that conceptually, it should be a shared space. But the reality is that our roads are ill suited for the task, catastrophically and obviously dangerous, and people insist on trying it anyway because in principle, it should work.
It feels like bikers think they're the only ones shouldering the risk of having their lives destroyed if things go sideways. As a driver, that's not how it feels. Maiming or killing a biker would be strictly worse for the biker, but I'm not excited about living in the aftermath either. It feels like bikers increase the risk of a terrible thing happening to both of us.
For me, that's what makes it a moral gray area: bikers definitely have the environmental upper hand. But they do it by engaging in activity that is borderline reckless given the reality of American roads. I find it difficult to enthusiastically encourage that.
Open to having my views changed on this.
In the late 1970s-early 1980s when cyclists started calling for bike lanes and changes to laws, part of the deal was that cyclists would adopt smart habits AKA the rules of the road, that helped them become part of a shared car-bike system. Things like wearing helmets, signaling turns, riding in the same direction as traffic. A lot of the rules are designed to make cyclists' behavior less unpredictable and thus safer.
I see this system breaking down when cyclists do dumb things like riding the wrong way on a street and swerving across lanes. (I'm probably showing my age but I mostly notice this from fixed-gear cyclists).
As a mostly car driver myself now, I want to ensure that bikes are safe. But it requires the cooperation
I've never understood how riding in the same direction is safer. The rider can't see me, so it feels like I'm creeping up on them. I feel there should be some degree of coordination when a car is approaching a bike, some eye contact, you know? But that can't be done when they're riding in the same direction.
I've never ridden a bike in traffic before, but I'm sure I'd feel really nervous to have an unknown set of cars approaching me from behind and passing by me unexpectedly.
Is it about reducing the relative velocity between them? I'm sure it's still significantly high even when going in the same direction.
EDIT: Here, I'm mostly thinking in the context of highways. It may be that the rule makes more sense in a city- or suburban-like environment.
A driver needs to check both ways in a sequence, with the final visual check being for traffic in the incoming lanes they are about to enter or cross. They check for pedestrians coming the opposite way first, but the slow rate of pedestrian movement means that the conditions do not change dramatically while the driver attention switches to the opposite direction. However, a cyclist/skater/scooter flying into the picture from the blind side is at great risk of collision with the driver who is now checking the opposite direction and initiating their maneuver.
There would be many more of these normal bicyclists if they didn't have to choose between legal danger (on sidewalk) and extreme physical danger (on road).
As a third party observing several of these events, I noticed that the cyclist/scooter rider/skateboarder more often accelerates to attempt to make a stale light as well, quite the opposite of normal pedestrian patterns. This has only gotten worse in recent years, with many more people having motor-assisted wheeled contraptions and not a lot of common sense about their newfound speed.
Cyclists should use their best judgment as to whether the sidewalk or street would be safer in a given area but there are even areas in cities where it’s illegal to ride the bike on the sidewalk.
It does a huge disservice to less-athletic people who might benefit from bicycle use. These people are far too slow to be in the road. They really need to be on the sidewalk. They could go in the road opposite to traffic, pulling off whenever a car approaches. Either way, they would walk the bicycle through intersections.
The typical bicycle user is far more like a pedestrian than like a car, and ought to be legislated as such, but our laws were written for the most serious and dedicated bicycle users.
The vast majority of roads are ill suited for bikes in our area (Asheville NC). The roads are narrow, curvy, blind and there is rarely even a shoulder. Bikers are in danger so much I don't know how they stomach it. I see them a lot of side walks which just endangers pedestrians.
It seems they cause traffic build up (people wanting to pass safely) which just enrages drivers and want to lash out at these "idiots" for being on these kinda roads in the first place.
Also it should be mandatory for bikers to wear lights - not just reflectors - so as to be almost painfully visible. It's not difficult to put rear blinkers + front light on a bike.
> Open to having my views changed on this.
If you agree that a world with more cyclists would be better (for the environment, for safety, maybe for public health), how do you suggest we get there? Encouraging change towards a better world often requires swimming upstream, shouldering some stress and discomfort and pressure, in order to exert pressure back on the system one wants to change.
Nobody will build safer bicycle infrastructure if nobody rides bicycles.
It simply doesn't match the reality of how drivers behave.
First, motorists often just have no idea how to drive sensibly around bikes and do weird things that contravene road laws and common sense - not leaving any passing margin, passing way too close right before red lights, cutting off bikes that they've just overtaken to turn right.
Second, motorists will get aggressive and impatient with cyclists that are riding in the most perfectly considerate and legal way. I've seen motorists get irritated with cyclists if they get delayed more than a second or two. That happens all the time with other cars - if the car in front of you is turning, it's going to delay you the same amount as if you have to slow down to safely overtake a cyclist. It goes both ways too - some motorists get upset if you ride in a textbook manner (occupying a lane as needed, doing hook turns, etc) and some get upset if you don't do that (they think you should be riding in the gutter or the sidewalk or whatever).
Third, if you look around, you'll see cars breaking minor traffic laws more frequently than people. In my old neighbourhood I kept an eye on how often different vehicles blew through stop signs, and cars did it with frequency and in far more dangerous ways than bikes. Just look at the statistics about how many deaths are attributed to cars behaving badly versus bikes.
The only way I can explain it is two things. First, people get confused when they have to interact with cyclists, because they don't really know what they're doing, and as a result get frustrated and angry. Second, motorists are primed to be annoyed at cyclists because they're different. It's hard to get annoyed at the car in front of you delaying you by a few seconds by its simple presence, because you yourself are also a person in a car.
The complaints about cyclists doing this that and the other are red herrings - if cyclists stopped doing them, the people complaining would find another way to rationalize their frustration.
I think all road users should up their game, but it's cars that are the big problem.
From the biker's perspective, your driving a car on the road is increasing the risk of something bad happening to both of you.
I'm not disputing that you have no choice but to drive a car on the road, but it's quite possible that the biker is in the same situation.
My experience is that I used to bike often and now I don't. So this probably alleviates my surprise at say an inexperienced biker riding in the gutter, coming up on a parked car, and jutting out at the last minute. But a little bit of riding would get you this sense too - its probably the best way to change your perspective. It will also give you the superpower of knowing when a car is going to change lanes before it puts on its blinker.
When riding, my biggest worry was being creamed from behind on non-city roads where traffic is going much faster, and drivers tend to space out or expect to pass within inches. But this tension is totally on the specific drivers themselves, and the easy answer is for them to explicitly pass rather than viewing a bike as some kind of roadside decoration.
FWIW I wasn't a fan of bike lanes in general. They're redundant and constraining, creating an expectation that you'll ride in the door zone or through road hazards, backed up by a solid white line. I'd rather explicitly share the right lane with cars rather than have a fake division. (Well-done bike lanes like modern NYC obviously change this)
"Get a car" - seriously?
- Riding on a bike/pedestrian overpass going OVER an intersection. - Riding on a bike path that is separated by grass from and parallel to a road. - Waiting at a crosswalk light for my turn to cross an intersection (while traveling on a bike path).
Cyclists are a frequent place for irrationally angry folks in cars to let out their anger.
But in my current country the riders ride on any road, sometimes on the side, sometimes as block of riders. It is more sporty type of riding rather than a commuter type of riding. Mixing it with cars cause a lot of stress to the car drivers because they have to slow or take over and be extra careful all the time. It is just annoying me both as a driver and as a bike rider. There is so much space on the footpath but I must ride on the road and try to keep up with much faster traffic.
If those drivers drive around smaller/slower cars do they get equally frustrated/angry?
Even if they do, what gives them the right too get angry at other participants in traffic that are legally using the road?
As to why in the US a lot more bike commuters are also into recreational biking, it's because of a feedback loop created in combination with bad bike supporting infrastructure and urban planning: the current situation means that in many places commuters have to share the road with cars, which means that only those that really like bike riding and/or are comfortable with a high level of stress/risk do it which, as it happens, it overlaps largely with the traits of those that enjoy recreational biking. With a lot of these riders on the road drivers get a sense of "these bikers are enjoying themselves and annoying me at the same time so they don't deserve respect" which further reinforces the current situation.