If one person were tortured to save the lives of 100, is that unethical. Possibly, but also possibly not.
The classic thought experiment around this is the trolley problem, where murdering innocents can save more lives than non-action.
None of this obtains in the torture case. Suppose you learn with certainty there is a bomb somewhere on Main Street, and you capture X, the evil bomber, with only 10 minutes to go. You want X to give you the exact location, because you don't have time to evacuate the whole street.
So you torture X...but what if he just gives you the wrong location? It will take you several minutes to check it out, and while you're doing so, the bomb goes off. You've failed. Even when you know for sure that the torture subject has the information you want there is delay between getting an answer and verifying it. In any ticking clock scenario the original malefactor can build in a plan for a diversion or the equivalent o a warrant canary to warn co-conspirators.
So what do you do? Send someone to check but act like you don't believe them and keep torturing X anyway? X knows it will take non-zero time to validate any answer and can structure the evil plot to take account of that. If you keep torturing X, you might just get a second decoy, plus there's now a strong argument that you're just doing it because you like it, and have picked a job which provides you with the excuse of necessity.
And ticking-clock-with-captured-terrorist scenarios are so rare in reality as to be nonexistent. Almost invariably torture is deployed either to terrorize people or to fish for information which the subject might or might not have. Generally, if prisoners won't supply the information an interrogator desires, they don't have it; and if they do have it, they're sufficiently strong-willed to withstand the torture. In a good many cases, the fact of torture motivates them to hold out, because it validates their moral opposition to a power that tortures people in the first place.
Yeah no.
You write that as if it is an indisputable law of nature. It's been debated in philosophy/ethics forever. Like most controversial ethical issues, it's unsettled at best.
> It really doesn’t matter how effective it is.
Many would disagree. If proven effective, you could easily argue it is moral to torture an evil-doer to save the lives of many.
Life isn't black and white. It's a lot of gray. You are free to believe what you want, but I just don't like the absolute moralizing - especially when it comes to controversial topics.
Neither of these things are an actual argument. Just because some people disagree it does not make a fact untrue. Just because you can argue something does not make that arguement correct.
The argument that many good lives would be saved is defeated by the fact that a society that tortures people is making a mockery of human dignity and the values that can underpin human happiness. When one person can be tortured for extreme need, soon anyone can be tortured for any reason. There are countless examples of this kind of slippage, from the terrors in France and Russia to the use of extreme surveillance by local authorities in the UK (to determine if school places should be allocated). How can anyone be happy when they might be taken and tortured at any moment? How can the preservation of people in terror be a goal to be accomplished by an intrinsically evil act.
We are defined by how we dispense mercy and compassion, that is what makes society worth preserving.
> “Evidence suggests that torture does not work, but media often show that it does,” Kearns said.
They did get some intelligence - from conventional interrogation and debriefing of prisoners.
Wouldn't that make torture potentially effective in cases without those issues, such as torturing someone to get them to reveal a password to an encrypted device that you know they use daily?
People have been arrested and held because they had Truecrypt installed but never actually used it.
Basically if you decrypt the device what are you looking for? What if you don't find it?
Suppose you know facts A, B, C, and D. You want to know E. You ask about all 5 facts. You can verify 4 out of 5, but you don't reveal that. After getting the 5 answers, you trust fact E if the other facts are verified. If not, torture, but don't reveal how exactly you are sure about lying, and then try again.
Given that they don't want to tell you E in the first place, how many of the hundreds of answers they'll scream at you are you going to be able to follow up on?
What you're actually going to do is here the answer you already know, stop the pain and ask something else, and thus tell the person exactly what to say to make the pain stop - while having no actual ability to know if there answer for E is truthful or if they even know it. Eventually you'll get an answer you like, and that will be the only answer they give because again, it made the pain stop.
The items A, B, C, and D are all known. (from other sources of information) They are used as an honesty test.
To make the pain stop, the only way out is to reveal E and to correctly reveal A, B, C, and D. Lying isn't going to work, because the fact that E is special is not revealed.
It isn't reasonable to guess that E is the unknown.
That's the stakes here when you're at that point: fear of death is not enough motivation, fear of not dying quickly is.
In this situation there's no reason the person isn't going to lie for an extended period of time about A, B, C and D. So why wouldn't they then lie about E? Because you think you're going to have broken them by that time? Gotten them suitably fearful of what you'll do next that they don't also just start lying about E? Are you so sure that after whatever horrors you've inflicted their psyche will be intact enough to even give a coherent answer? Keeping in mind, that sleep deprivation and extended interrogation has been shown - repeatedly - to be enough to make otherwise innocent people confess to brutal crimes they did not commit.
EDIT: People keep thinking torture is effective because if I broke your fingers with a hammer, you'd give me your car keys. What's actually happening is I'm breaking your fingers one by one with a hammer, and saying I'll stop if you tell me where your family is so I can go murder them all.
> In this situation there's no reason the person isn't going to lie for an extended period of time about A, B, C and D. So why wouldn't they then lie about E?
You seem to be thinking about this in chronological sequence, as if we ask about A then B then C then D then E. If that was the case, then yes, your logic would work. They might have lied about A for a long time, then B for a long time, then C for a long time, then D for a long time, then E for a long time and you'd never know if they were telling the truth about E.
But that's not what is being proposed. We ask about A, B, C, D, and E altogether. As in you have conversation and asked them about A, B, C, D, and E before doing any torture. If they lied about A, B, C, or D we torture them. Then we have the same conversation again, and torture them again. Eventually, they start telling the truth about say C. Why C? They are just choosing something at random to tell truth about in hopes of making the pain stop. But nothing changes, we keep torturing them because we know they are still lying about A, B, and D. Eventually they also start telling the truth about A, then E, then B, then D. Then we stop torturing them because they are being honest about everything we can verify. They can escape without divulging the information only if they keep E until last.
The key assumption here is that the person being tortured reveals the truth in a random order. It is improbable that they happen to keep the one thing we cannot verify until the end.
This is not to say that this procedure would be effective, but its not ineffective for the reason you suggest.
On the theory side, the probability of keeping E until the end is 1/5, which isn't that low.
On the practical side, this requires that the person being tortured has no idea what you can and can't verify. If, instead, they have some idea of what you can and can't verify, they'll be able to keep the hardest to verify information till the end preventing this scheme from working.
That this is awful does not make it untrue.
If it makes everyone feel better, the tech to simply "read" your secrets out of your brain with no torture whatsoever will likely soon exist (or already does).
That said, a lot of torture is performed not to extract information but to instill terror, etc.