52 ~line~ [edit: character] summary
Then write a book, just being sure to wrap at 72 chars. Never really considered what an optimal commit message length was.
Maybe it's something along the lines of "if you are playing poker and you can't figure out who the easy money is, the easy money is you." I've never seen a commit message, PR description, etc and thought "well that was excessive," so maybe I'm the one...
This one stood out to me: 157 lines of rationale, discussion of alternatives, etc for 22 lines of uncontroversial changes[1]. It's much more likely to be useful in and of itself as a piece of documentation than a one-liner, "Changes to prevent strcpy" though.
[1]: https://github.com/git/git/commit/c8af66ab8ad7cd78557f0f9f5e...