Rate my startup: Fasterplan, a social appointment finder without sign-up
So, what do you think about it? Ah, this is the url: www.fasterplan.com
So, what do you think about it? Ah, this is the url: www.fasterplan.com
I couldn't understand from the opening splash what it really did, so I went to the "tour". 30 seconds in I was bored, still didn't really know what was going on, hated the music, closed it and left.
From what I can gather you create a "billboard," get an obscure URL, send that to your friends, then you all edit the shared space.
Yes?
So two points. Firstly, don't show me the details of how to do stuff - I need to be convinced that it will solve a problem I actually have, and I need to be convinced within 30 seconds (or hooked long enough to keep watching.)
Secondly, most people I know either have trouble editing a shared space and prefer email, or use Facebook to arrange get-togethers. From what I saw in the first few seconds (and I did scan forward to see what else happened) you need to find a way to make it much, much, much simpler. As it stands, tech-savvy people will find a better way, tech-non-savvy people won't cope.
I hope that helps - I've tried to be constructive.
For curiousity: how would you as a tech-savvy person solve the problem of finding a common appointment?
> ... how would you ... solve the problem
> of finding a common appointment?
I wrote a small cgi. I put people in it, it lists dates. Everyone clicks days they're available, and it colors the dates more green for more people available, more red for fewer people available. After everyone has visited it's pretty clear what date or dates work best.I don't use Facebook, so I don't know what's there, but I'm sure people just open some sort of communal space or topic or whatever and use that. I've seen something like that go past in notifications.
And I guessed what it was about because I have the problem, I've thought about what I want, I've written many components that work well enough for me, I realized your app was targetted at that, and I thought it looked too overladen and complex.
I also didn't try it because it looks from the video that it needs a fast, modern browser, so I'd have to change machines and get things started. Can't be bothered.
I think you made a good point about a more understandable presentation of the idea. I disagree that tech savvy people would not use the site, because even though I consider myself tech savvy, I would rather spend some minutes googling for some webpage that does what I want then writing my own script. In any case, Fasterplan should be usable by non tech savvy people, too, and I will work on that.
If you have unique features that Facebook doesn't already provide, I rec integrating with the Facebook platform. >500M people can instantly use your product. That's powerful. Also, you may want to consider finding a good graphic designer because the design is a bit lacking (quite typical of us engineers ;)
With Facebook integration, you mean for example that users could identify themselves with their Facebook accounts (like if they are already logged in they would appear as such)? So they would not have to enter their name when scheduling an event. Maybe that is a good idea. On the other hand I want to leave Fasterplan open to people who do not have a Facebook account (they still exist, and if only one of them is in your group of friends then this blows up the ogranization).
Apart from that, I would like to know: were you able to create a billboard and add something to it? Do you think less tech savvy people can use the platform? Or is it too complicated? Is the principal idea clear from the initial explication, or did you expect something different after reading it?
Also, when clicking the buttons I noticed a lot of AJAX going on, which took some time. I was a little confused here because there was no direct feedback. Maybe you can add a rotating spinner or something equivalent.
That said, of course I commend you for actually creating something :)