==the last thing you would want is the public questioning every single thing. Because they will. If they don’t, the opposition party certainly will.==
And if you classify it wouldn't that also cause the public to question "every single thing" just the same? Seems like the case we have proves that to be true as they hid it and people are still questioning.
Replace the cities or issue with anything you want. The point is, something has to be prioritized, and the ones who aren't prioritized could be seen as victimized.
However, no politician/official necessarily wants to be on record as making this kind of priority decision.
So if you insist on radical transparency in these situations, you're insisting on people being less effective.
But even if you assume that politicians have misaligned incentives because they care more about optics than saving lives, why reduce transparency? You're making the assumption there are more good decisions with bad optics than bad decisions with bad optics. Which seems like an unlikely assumption to be true.
Agreed. I was referring to the principle of the thing, not this specific instance.
> You're making the assumption there are more good decisions with bad optics than bad decisions with bad optics. Which seems like an unlikely assumption to be true.
I think it might be true in certain situations, e.g. emergency situations like we're in now.