In fact, the stark difference between Italy and Germany would provide support to the paper's conclusion.
In fact, the stark difference between Italy and Germany would provide support to the paper's conclusion.
My hypothesis is that this comes from bigger inter-generation connections in Italy.
* assume false positive rate of 10%, assume true positive rate of 100% (it's not but let's be generous)
* maybe 1/10 of the population (30 million) gets tested
* lets say 100,000 people have COVID right now (50x the official number)
number of positive tests = 30 million * 0.1 + 100k * 1 = 3,100,000
fraction of postive tests that actually have the disease = 1 / 31 = 3.2%
problem is FPR (1) depends on the population tested (i.e. p(covid | positive test) != p(covid|positive test, some symptoms) != ...), (2) we need very accurate measurements of FPR because:
lets say we constrain FPR to 10% +/- 1% ==> 10% uncertainty in FPR -- that means our inference of the number of infected people is:
n_infected = (n_positive_tests - FPR * n_tested)
which is: -200,000 to 400,000
so...not very useful.