He didn't necessarily take responsibility of anything, but he managed to suppress his usual behavior well enough for the people behind him to assure people
If you’re trying to say “who cares about money when lives are on the line”... in this case a strong, life-saving, response begets a positive market response.
People drying en-masse is not good for the economy, or anyone really. Also, recessions are generally not good for people’s health.
Trump going up there and making a bunch of positive statements means zero right now. The public and private sectors have no reason to trust the federal government during this situation.
Literally no one but yourself has implied the stock market going well means Coronavirus is going away.
That’s so absurd I gave you the benefit of the doubt and assumed something was lost in your wording...
The comment chain is about the effect of the virus on electability of an incumbent.
The stock market’s performance is very much tied to that and while not the only indicator of an election's outcome, is a pretty strong motivator of political change.
On that note... since his speech a ton of bad news has come out, some his claims were proven false, the fed hit the nuclear options, and futures hit a circuit breaker Sunday night which is a terrible indicator for this morning’s market.
So it’s still a strong factor in his electability, just not in the direction it was Friday evening.
On the other hand, it's much easier to rally people when your villain has an actual human face.
That should have a footnote. Pancho Villa's División del Norte invaded the US in a raid on Columbus, NM in 1916. The Japanese Army occupied the small and remote Aleutian islands of Attu and Kiska during WWII. These are both minor incidents, hence a footnote.
If we expand "US soil" beyond the U.S. continent (or the 50 states), then the Japanese occupations of the Philippines, Guam and Wake Island should also count.
The Commonwealth of the Philippines was not fully independent from the US. Guam is an organized territory of the US, and Wake Island is an unorganized, unincorporated territory of the US. (I'm not sure about their exact territorial status in WWII though.)
has never had to deal with a war on US soil since Lincoln
There were agents of both the Central Powers and Axis Powers active on US soil, and in WW2 Japan attacked Hawai'i and occupied many US territories (Alaska, Philippines, Guam, Wake).No it's not. You had every expert in the world talking about the potential dangers for months, while Trump kept talking about how it was just a flu that would magically go away on its own, and that there wasn't anything to be concerned with. The US's preparation has been incredibly bad and late in comparison to certain other countries. On top of Trump firing the Pandemic Response Team in 2018.
The optics are going to start looking increasingly bad for him as the US death rate starts to climb.
I don't claim to predict the outcome of the election, but you can't claim that it's "hard to criticize the government" based off of this, or that any future "decisive action" is going to be enough once the death rate hits tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands.
Experts have been also talking about dangers of climate change for years, yet Trump manages to win election while calling climate change a hoax. So not sure his base cares about expert advice.
>while Trump kept talking about how it was just a flu that would magically go away on its own, and that there wasn't anything to be concerned with.
You should read trump's tweets, there is a shockingly large number of people agreeing with him on this like everything.
As long as trump can manage to limit the damage to the US, he will have strong arguments for a re-election.
Ah yes, yet another person who looked at the Snopes piece's headline and nothing else. One would think reading it, and the Twitter thread it is based on, that to save money (or because the Trump administration hates science, or something) the entire "US Pandemic Response Team" agency was cut to save money, causing everyone in a large DC office building to lose their jobs.
Actually reading the contemporary NBC News https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/politics-news/tom-bossert-t... and Washington Post https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/to-your-health/wp/2018/0... articles it cites, they seem to have been a handful of people in one team in the National Security Council hierarchy, that the new National Security Advisor reassigned to related agencies. Ziemer resigned because he wanted to keep his team the way it was.
COVID19 was not a surprise; that is, it was known to exist in China some time before the first cases appeared in the US. It is not unreasonable for a government to assemble a team to respond to something like a pandemic as needed, as opposed to having people dedicated solely to the purpose and nothing else. And that's exactly what the US did, implementing the ban on non-American travelers who'd been to China in late January, among other things.
You may or may not agree with this. But please don't claim that this is somehow prima facie proof of the Trump administration's malfeasance/evilness.
PS - No, Trump did not "cut the CDC budget!" either. https://apnews.com/d36d6c4de29f4d04beda3db00cb46104
To another reply: you're correct, this is a big point that few people are thinking about.
The comparison between how the different countries will care for their population is unavoidable, and the results in China will be proudly stellar in that time (They had reasons to be proud).
And this can't be solved with more fake news. Death values can be faked and anybody could start a badmouth campaign against South Korea to hide that they will have the lowest mortality rate (due to the korean strategy of extensive testing of the population) but in the end, death people will not vote you (neither their widows, friends and family?).
So It depends also of how people will feel about replacing Obamacare by Trumpcare. Images from the past like "Trump throwing rolls of toilet paper to puerto ricans with contempt" will not help by comparison. He always had problems showing real empathy in public.
I think it will be far more important how Trump deals with this than the simple fact of it happening.
Biden might be washed up, but it might not matter. Bloomberg is about to drop $2 Billion in advertising and infrastructure in support of the Democratic party.
I'm not saying Trump is going to lose, but if he wins, it's going to be by a narrow margin in which he loses the popular vote by more than 6 million.
1) Almost everyone in the world who is susceptible has it, or had it.
2) We implemented a way to slow down the global growth rate, or it slowed down by itself.
One way or another, we will know in a just a few months.
If you want to check the math, skip to about 3:20 on this video from 3Blue1Brown, Exponential growth and epidemics.
The problem is than when we will reach summer, half of the planet will start the winter. A interesting question is if the coronavirus will be able to hide in the southern hemisphere or not. That would start and endless migration cycle from now on.
a lot of people died in Italy https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/italy/
I think we are at the point where we will see a lot of infections. I think we will see a lot of death from this as well, but it will be at the lower end of the case fatality rate range as long as we can do the things we need to in order to not overwhelm our healthcare system. If however I am wrong, and we do overwhelm the healthcare system like they did in Italy, yea, there is going to be a lot more death.
See the chart in this article for details on the 11 day difference. https://www.econlib.org/the-answer-one-week/
Here is why I don't think they are enough.
1) Isolation is not uniform across the country. Some people are working from home. Others aren't. Some schools are closed. Some aren't. Some trips are cancelled. Some planes are still flying with some people. There are still large areas of the country where it's spreading with little or no isolation. The cases there will grow, and walk across state borders.
2) It's not enough, yet. We have some isolation in some spots. But there's not yet even one single spot with measures as drastic as are needed to stop this.
Italy has had stricter measures than the US in place for a little while, and the number of new people seeking hospital care per day is still growing.
The places which have successfully turned this thing around have put measures in place much more drastic than the US, and on a consistent national basis.
---
I guess we disagree about the US being more isolated than Italy or not. I think Italy has more isolation in place. Please let me know in what ways things here are more isolated than Italy.