Hacker News Reader

Comment by e_proxus | Hacker News Reader

Just wait until you try the front facing camera on a MacBook (in my case, the Air from 2019). It's so horrible compared to any recent iDevice from the last years. I don't understand why they don't improve them to match the mobile quality at least.

View on HN

It would be nice if they improved it, but I think they have their priority right at least... people are taking a lot of actual photographs with their phone selfie camera while the computer camera is mostly for video conferencing.

This might shed some light as to why: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BLgS7m0W94

tl;dr: phone webcams have DMA, laptop webcams are using USB.

I guess Apple would be in a unique position here to use their experience from mobile to make a better integrated webcam in their computers as well, without most of those limitations.

This seems like a dubious explanation; you can get quite high-quality external webcams that use USB 2.0.

I'd say a more likely (and harder to fix) explanation is that the phone ones can be deeper; laptop ones have to be very slim to fit.

It could just be a question of pricing. Maybe high quality phone cameras are available for very cheap, while USB 2.0 cameras with good image quality are not available for cheap from any vendors. There might not be any rational reason why this is beyond offer and demand.

Exactly. You want thinner bezel, slimmer Screen, and the trade off is simply the camera. Unfortunately there doesn't seems to be enough interest in it for Apple to innovate.

They could put a notch into the Macbook screen. /s

DO NOT GIVE TIM COOK IDEAS.

good thin cameras are hard to make. phones are much thicker than your display.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com